Easy Earn And Go - Investing and Stock News
  • Stock Market
  • Investment News
  • Latest News
  • Economy
  • Stock Market
  • Investment News
  • Latest News
  • Economy
No Result
View All Result
Easy Earn And Go - Investing and Stock News - Investing and Stock News
No Result
View All Result
Home Latest News

Supreme Court divided over state effort to defund Planned Parenthood

admin by admin
April 3, 2025
in Latest News
0
Supreme Court divided over state effort to defund Planned Parenthood
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Supreme Court appeared divided Wednesday over whether a state can block Medicaid funding for Planned Parenthood clinics, in a technical interpretation over healthcare choices that has become a larger political fight over abortion access.

In nearly two hours of oral arguments, the court’s conservative majority offered measured support for South Carolina’s position.

The specific issue is whether low-income Medicaid patients can sue in order to choose their own qualified healthcare provider. The federal-state program has shared responsibility for funding and administering it, through private healthcare providers.

Federal law bans taxpayer money from going to fund almost all abortions, but Planned Parenthood also provides a range of other medical services with and without Medicaid subsidies, including gynecological care and cancer screenings.

Blocking the provider from Medicaid networks could effectively defund it. Given the divisive underlying issue of abortion, groups on both sides rallied outside the high court ahead of the arguments. 

The state’s governor in 2018 signed an executive order blocking Medicaid funding for the state’s two Planned Parenthood clinics, saying it amounted to taxpayers subsidizing abortions. 

Courts have put that order on hold, leading to the current case. 

South Carolina now bans abortion around six weeks of pregnancy, or when cardiac activity is detected, with limited exceptions. 

The key provision in the 1965 Medicaid Act guarantees patients a ‘free choice of provider’ that is willing and qualified. 

Much of the court session dealt with whether Planned Parenthood was a ‘qualified provider’ under the Medicaid law, and whether individual patients have an unambiguous ‘right’ to sue to see their provider of choice, under its specific language.

‘It seems a little bit odd to think that a problem that motivated Congress to pass this provision was that states were limiting the choices people had,’ said Justice Sonia Sotomayor. ‘It seems hard to understand that states didn’t understand that they had to give individuals the right to choose a provider.’

‘The state has an obligation to ensure that a person… has a right to choose their doctor,’ added Justice Elena Kagan. ‘It’s impossible to even say the thing without using the word ‘right.”

But some conservative justices questioned how to interpret a provision that does not contain the word ‘right.’

‘One can imagine a statute written as an individual benefit that’s mandatory on the states but isn’t right-creating’ for the patient, said Justice Neil Gorsuch. ‘I mean, that’s an imaginable scenario.’ 

Justice Samuel Alito added it was ‘something that’s quite extraordinary’ to give individuals that right to sue under the Constitution’s spending clause. 

The votes of Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett could be key: They asked tough questions of both sides.

Barrett offered a hypothetical of the right of a patient to go to court over their doctor accused of medical malpractice. ‘Does it make sense in that circumstance for Congress to want plaintiffs to be able to sue?’ she asked.

Planned Parenthood says its future is at stake, noting nearly $700 million – about a third of its overall nationwide revenue – originates from Medicaid reimbursements, and government grants and contracts.

But the group notes just $90,000 in Medicaid funding goes to Planned Parenthood facilities every year in South Carolina, which is comparatively small to the state’s total Medicaid spending.

Julie Edwards, a South Carolina resident, sued along with Planned Parenthood South Atlantic, which operates two clinics in Columbia and Charleston. She has type-1 diabetes and associated medical complications and wanted to choose the Columbia clinic for its range of services, including reproductive care. 

A federal appeals court ruled against the state in 2024, concluding the ‘free choice of provider’ provision ‘specifies an entitlement given to each Medicaid beneficiary: to choose one’s preferred qualified provider without state interference.’

In a 2023 Supreme Court opinion involving care for nursing home residents, the justices concluded that a different law from Medicaid gives individuals the right to sue. 

A year earlier, the high court overturned its Roe v. Wade precedent of a nationwide right to abortion.

Several states – including Texas, Missouri and Arkansas – have already done what South Carolina wants to do by cutting Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood and more could follow if South Carolina prevails. 

‘The people in this state do not want their tax money to go to that organization,’ said Republican South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster, who attended the oral argument. ‘I believe the decision of this court will be that the people of South Carolina have the right to make this decision for themselves, for our state. Other states may make a different decision, but not ours. South Carolina stands for the right to life, and we’ll do whatever is necessary to protect that.’

The Trump Justice Department is supporting the state, and abortion rights groups say the issue is about patient choice.

‘Our health centers serve an irreplaceable role in the state’s healthcare system, providing birth control and cancer screenings to people who can’t afford those services anywhere else,’ said Paige Johnson, interim president and CEO of Planned Parenthood South Atlantic. ‘Government officials should never block people from getting healthcare or be able to decide which doctor you can or cannot see.’ 

One concern raised by healthcare advocates is finding gynecological and family planning services in states with limited facilities. Low-income women often have greater difficulty traveling long distances to get such quality care, a requirement for Medicaid providers.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh said he would make it his mission to bring as much clarity over when patients can go to court, which he called a 45-year ‘odyssey.’

Much of the public arguments dealt with whether a ‘right’ to sue was a magic word to automatically decide the matter.

‘I’m not allergic to magic words, because magic words – if they represent the principle – will provide the clarity that will avoid the litigation that is a huge waste of resources for states, courts, providers, beneficiaries.’

The case is Medina (SC DOH) v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic (23-1275). A ruling is likely by early summer.

This post appeared first on FOX NEWS

Previous Post

Alibaba seen as a better AI stock than Nvidia and a hedge against tariff risks

Next Post

OXLC stock yields 22% and beats S&P 500: is it a good buy?

Next Post
OXLC stock yields 22% and beats S&P 500: is it a good buy?

OXLC stock yields 22% and beats S&P 500: is it a good buy?

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Hamas terrorists torture protester to death in Gaza, leave his body on family’s doorstep: report

Hamas terrorists torture protester to death in Gaza, leave his body on family’s doorstep: report

April 1, 2025
UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson murder case: DOJ to seek death penalty for Luigi Mangione

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson murder case: DOJ to seek death penalty for Luigi Mangione

April 2, 2025
Sell Webull stock: here’s why it may be headed for a crash

Sell Webull stock: here’s why it may be headed for a crash

April 15, 2025
XRP price prediction: How high would it go if most US banks integrated Ripple?

XRP price prediction: How high would it go if most US banks integrated Ripple?

April 24, 2025
SCHD ETF forecast for June and top catalysts to watch

SCHD ETF forecast for June and top catalysts to watch

0
Will the S&P 500 rebound in April after its worst monthly drop since 2022?

Will the S&P 500 rebound in April after its worst monthly drop since 2022?

0
Hamas terrorists torture protester to death in Gaza, leave his body on family’s doorstep: report

Hamas terrorists torture protester to death in Gaza, leave his body on family’s doorstep: report

0
Nio stock price has crashed: is it safe to buy the dip?

Nio stock price has crashed: is it safe to buy the dip?

0
SCHD ETF forecast for June and top catalysts to watch

SCHD ETF forecast for June and top catalysts to watch

June 5, 2025
Elon Musk posts ‘Kill Bill’ meme in latest push to nix Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’

Elon Musk posts ‘Kill Bill’ meme in latest push to nix Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’

June 5, 2025
Citi downgrades CEG stock despite Constellation Energy’s big deal with Meta

Citi downgrades CEG stock despite Constellation Energy’s big deal with Meta

June 5, 2025
Nationwide coordinated retail crime crackdown results in hundreds of arrests, authorities say

Nationwide coordinated retail crime crackdown results in hundreds of arrests, authorities say

June 5, 2025
Enter Your Information Below To Receive Trading Ideas and Latest News

    Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!

    Recent News

    SCHD ETF forecast for June and top catalysts to watch

    SCHD ETF forecast for June and top catalysts to watch

    June 5, 2025
    Elon Musk posts ‘Kill Bill’ meme in latest push to nix Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’

    Elon Musk posts ‘Kill Bill’ meme in latest push to nix Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’

    June 5, 2025
    Citi downgrades CEG stock despite Constellation Energy’s big deal with Meta

    Citi downgrades CEG stock despite Constellation Energy’s big deal with Meta

    June 5, 2025
    Nationwide coordinated retail crime crackdown results in hundreds of arrests, authorities say

    Nationwide coordinated retail crime crackdown results in hundreds of arrests, authorities say

    June 5, 2025
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 easyearnandgo.com | All Rights Reserved

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Stock Market
    • Investment News
    • Latest News
    • Economy

    Copyright © 2025 easyearnandgo.com | All Rights Reserved